How the estimator works
The disputed amount is your estimate minus the carrier’s. Appraisal panels rarely award everything one side asks for, so the slider lets you pick where the award might land inside that gap. The tool then subtracts your appraiser’s fee and, if you choose, half of an umpire’s fee, and shows the net increase. The scenario table repeats the math at 25%, 50% and 75% so you can see the range at a glance.
Reading the result
- Large gap, healthy net: appraisal may be worth a professional look.
- Narrow gap: a documented supplement request may close it faster and cheaper.
- Net near zero or negative: fees could absorb the recovery. Start with an estimate review.
Illustrative example
The default figures are illustrative only: a $16,800 carrier estimate against a $29,400 contractor estimate. They are not results from any real claim.
Questions about this tool
Is the award usually in the middle?
There is no rule. Awards depend on the evidence. The slider is a planning assumption, not a prediction.
Do I always pay half the umpire?
Many policies split umpire fees evenly. Check your policy’s appraisal clause.
Is anything I type saved?
No. The calculation runs in your browser and nothing is sent or stored.
